How we analyse and score
We compare watches using publicly available data, technical specifications and buyer reviews. This page explains the criteria we use, their weighting in the rankings and the limitations of our approach.
What “analysis” means here
We do not handle watches or carry out any physical testing. Our analyses draw on manufacturer information and feedback published by buyers. Information may be incomplete or change: always check the official specifications before buying.
A manufacturer's claimed specification is not measured performance, and a buyer's review is not a measured result. We keep these three types of evidence separate, both on the page and in our calculations.
Our evidence trail
- 1Exact modelThe full model name, variant and market. Two versions of the same product are never combined.
- 2Published dataManufacturer specifications and retailer listings for the exact model, recorded on a specific date.
- 3Catalogue comparisonEach value is compared with those of all other models on the same scale.
- 4Verdict in contextWho the model suits, and when to choose another.
Data we don't have stays missing. It is never guessed, replaced with an average or counted as zero.
How we assess watches
These criteria are fixed across the category and applied in the same order to every model. This lets you compare two analyses line by line, instead of reading two opinions that cover different things.
- Case diameter higher is better · mm
- Case thickness higher is better · mm
- Strap width higher is better · mm
- Water resistance higher is better · atm
- Weight lower is better · g
- Battery life higher is better · days
A criterion is scored only if the model's specification is documented. Across the site's 5 scored analyses: Case diameter out of 4, Case thickness out of 5, Strap width out of 4, Water resistance out of 5, Weight out of 3, Battery life out of 2, Equipment out of 2.
This is why each product page displays between 4 and 6 scores. Each page explains which criteria are not scored and why under “Our scores explained”.
A model is not marked down for a feature it never promised. It is assessed in the context of its price and intended users, using criteria relevant to its category.
How the score is calculated
The score out of 10 is the average of individual scores, one for each criterion in the table above. Each score reflects more than an impression: it shows themodel's ranking across the full cataloguefor that criterion. That is why each row includes supporting figures, such as “210 min, ahead of 80% of models in the catalogue”. You can cross-check them.
When our data does not cover a criterion for a particular model, the row makes this clear: it is presented as anassessment based on published specifications, rather than a measurement. The page clearly distinguishes between the two.
What we never do:
- fill in a missing specification with an assumption;
- score two models using different methods;
- turn a result that depends on user needs into an overall winner;
- publish a score when the data is too limited to support it.
A score reflects our assessment at a given point in time. It is relative to the catalogue: whenever scores are updated, every product page is recalculated against the current catalogue, so a score can change as new models are added.
Our sources and how we weigh them
- Manufacturer documentationOfficial pages, manuals and specification sheets. These establish what is claimed. Manufacturer claims are always presented as such.
- Retailer pagesThese confirm the exact model, included accessories and recorded price for the relevant market. A limited-time offer is never presented as a regular price.
- Customer feedbackWe look for recurring themes, rather than isolated comments, taking into account reviews covering different variants and the sample size.
- Published specialist analysesThese help us compare claims with observations. We do not copy their verdicts or average their scores.
When sources disagree, we flag this rather than force a conclusion.
Prices
We don't display prices next to retailer links. A price checked once soon goes out of date, and an incorrect figure next to a buy button lets down the reader it was meant to help. Prices shown in our tables and filters indicate a model's price range and help you filter by budget: the price that applies is the one shown by the retailer when you buy.
Independence and affiliate links
No brand pays to appear in our selections or improve its score. Some retailer links are affiliate links: if you buy through them, we may earn a commission,at no extra cost to you.
Whether we earn a commission, and how much, has no bearing on our criteria. Affiliate revenue funds the site; it does not determine our rankings.
Updates and corrections
An analysis is revised when a model changes, when data proves incorrect, or when new models shift its position in the catalogue. The last updated date remains visible on every page.
This site's content is written and checked by Alex B.. An error, outdated information, a missing model: let us know and we will correct the page.
View our analyses →